Book Top Rated Hotels in Pine Island, NY | Choice Hotels

Sleep Inn & Suites Middletown - Goshen
3491 Route 6,
Middletown, NY, 10940, US
13.82 km from Pine Island, NY
4.27 stars rating. Excellent. 1172 reviews4.27 stars rating. Excellent. 1172 reviews
Book Now & Save 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$272~~Discounted rate:$245USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Sleep Inn & Suites Monroe - Woodbury
1 Sleep Way,
Monroe, NY, 10950, US
23.38 km from Pine Island, NY
4.56 stars rating. Excellent. 1101 reviews4.56 stars rating. Excellent. 1101 reviews
Book Now & Save 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$235~~Discounted rate:$212USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Econo Lodge
448 Route 206 South,
Newton, NJ, 07860, US
39.91 km from Pine Island, NY
3.38 stars rating. Good. 567 reviews3.38 stars rating. Good. 567 reviews
Book Now & Save 5%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$99~~Discounted rate:$94USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Rodeway Inn Milford - I-84
240 Route 6,
Milford, PA, 18337, US
31.27 km from Pine Island, NY
3.9 stars rating. Good. 402 reviews3.9 stars rating. Good. 402 reviews
Book Now & Save 5%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$140~~Discounted rate:$133USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability

Change your dates to book properties below.

Quality Inn near Mountain Creek
15 Route 94,
Vernon, NJ, 07462, US
15.81 km from Pine Island, NY
3.61 stars rating. Good. 796 reviews3.61 stars rating. Good. 796 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
Comfort Suites Central Valley - Woodbury
100 Estrada Road,
Central Valley, NY, 10917, US
29.04 km from Pine Island, NY
No Reviews YetNo Reviews Yet
Coming soonStart booking Nov 02, 2025
See Availability

Other Pine Island searches

All Hotels in Pine Island

Boutique Hotels in Pine Island

Hotel Deals in Pine Island

Extended Stay Hotels in Pine Island

Pet Friendly Hotels in Pine Island

Good to know

Top-Rated hotels

6 hotels in Pine Island

Highest Price

$245

Lowest Price

$94

Avg. rating

3.3 (4038 reviews)