5 Top Rated hotels near Pine Island, NY

5 Top Rated hotels near Pine Island, NY

Show points
List
  • 43
    Sleep Inn & Suites Middletown - Goshen

    13.82 km from destination

    4.27 stars rating. Excellent. 1180 reviews
    Save 10%
    Strikethrough Rate:$128Discounted rate:$115USD/night
    Member Rate
  • 34
    Quality Inn near Mountain Creek

    15.81 km from destination

    3.61 stars rating. Good. 800 reviews
    Save 10%
    Strikethrough Rate:$102Discounted rate:$92USD/night
    Member Rate
  • 38
    Sleep Inn & Suites Monroe - Woodbury

    23.38 km from destination

    4.56 stars rating. Excellent. 1106 reviews
    Save 10%
    Strikethrough Rate:$135Discounted rate:$121USD/night
    Member Rate
  • 25
    Econo Lodge

    39.91 km from destination

    3.38 stars rating. Good. 567 reviews
    Save 7%
    Strikethrough Rate:$79Discounted rate:$73USD/night
    Member Rate
  • 25
    Rodeway Inn Milford - I-84

    31.27 km from destination

    3.9 stars rating. Good. 403 reviews
    Save 7%
    Strikethrough Rate:$100Discounted rate:$93USD/night
    Member Rate
Change your dates to book properties below.
  • 3
    Comfort Suites Central Valley - Woodbury

    29.04 km from destination

    No Reviews Yet
    Coming soonStart booking Nov 02, 2025

Other Pine Island searches

Good to know

Top-Rated hotels

6 hotels in Pine Island

Highest Price

$121

Lowest Price

$73

Avg. rating

3.3 (4056 reviews)