Hotels in Fire Island, NY – Choice Hotels

Clarion Hotel & Conference Center
3845 Veterans Memorial Highway,
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779, US
9.67 mi from Fire Island, NY
2.48 stars rating. Fair. 988 reviews2.48 stars rating. Fair. 988 reviews
Book Now & Save 5%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$315~~Discounted rate:$299USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island
2695 Route 112,
Medford, NY, 11763, US
14.33 mi from Fire Island, NY
3.94 stars rating. Good. 1180 reviews3.94 stars rating. Good. 1180 reviews
$466USD/night
See Availability
Comfort Inn Syosset-Long Island
24 Oak Drive,
Syosset, NY, 11791, US
22.35 mi from Fire Island, NY
4.14 stars rating. Very Good. 1547 reviews4.14 stars rating. Very Good. 1547 reviews
Book Now & Save 8%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$426~~Discounted rate:$392USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport
3055 Veterans Memorial Hwy., SR454,
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779, US
9.76 mi from Fire Island, NY
3.6 stars rating. Good. 729 reviews3.6 stars rating. Good. 729 reviews
Book Now & Save 7%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$149~~Discounted rate:$139USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability

Change your dates to book properties below.

Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island
110 Vanderbilt Motor Parkway,
Hauppauge, NY, 11788, US
12.58 mi from Fire Island, NY
2.21 stars rating. Fair. 249 reviews2.21 stars rating. Fair. 249 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
Econo Lodge
429 Duffy Ave.,
Hicksville, NY, 11801, US
22.47 mi from Fire Island, NY
4.04 stars rating. Very Good. 1372 reviews4.04 stars rating. Very Good. 1372 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
Rodeway Inn Huntington Station - Melville
270 West Jericho Turnpike,
Huntington Station, NY, 11746, US
19.02 mi from Fire Island, NY
2.3 stars rating. Fair. 325 reviews2.3 stars rating. Fair. 325 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability

Other Fire Island searches

All Hotels in Fire Island

Boutique Hotels in Fire Island

Hotel Deals in Fire Island

Extended Stay Hotels in Fire Island

Pet Friendly Hotels in Fire Island

Top Rated Hotels in Fire Island

Good to know

Number of hotels

7 hotels in Fire Island

Highest Price

$466

Lowest Price

$139

Avg. rating

3.2 (6390 reviews)