Book Mainstay Hotels in Old Bethpage, NY

Below are additional hotels in the area that do not match your exact search criteria.

Comfort Inn Syosset-Long Island
24 Oak Drive,
Syosset, NY, 11791, US
4.56 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.12 stars rating. Very Good. 1579 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 5%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$190~~Discounted rate:$180USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
AWARD WINNER
Econo Lodge Hicksville - Long Island
429 Duffy Ave.,
Hicksville, NY, 11801, US
5.04 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.05 stars rating. Very Good. 1408 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$213~~Discounted rate:$192USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Rodeway Inn Huntington Station - Melville
270 West Jericho Turnpike,
Huntington Station, NY, 11746, US
4.88 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
2.28 stars rating. Fair. 336 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 5%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$119~~Discounted rate:$114USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island
110 Vanderbilt Motor Parkway,
Hauppauge, NY, 11788, US
10.36 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
2.25 stars rating. Fair. 322 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 7%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$199~~Discounted rate:$185USD/night
Special Rate
See Availability
Blue Angel Hotel NYC, an Ascend Collection Hotel
152 E. 55th Street,
New York, NY, 10022, US
27.01 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.38 stars rating. Excellent. 734 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 9%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$183~~Discounted rate:$167USD/night
Member Rate
Fees included
See Availability
Mayfair Hotel, an Ascend Collection Hotel
242 W 49th Street,
New York, NY, 10019, US
27.88 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.34 stars rating. Excellent. 845 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 4%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$159~~Discounted rate:$152USD/night
Member Rate
Fees included
See Availability
Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport
3055 Veterans Memorial Hwy., SR454,
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779, US
16.59 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
3.58 stars rating. Good. 744 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 5%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$119~~Discounted rate:$113USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Clarion Hotel & Conference Center Ronkonkoma MacArthur Airport
3845 Veterans Memorial Highway,
Ronkonkoma, NY, 11779, US
18.08 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
2.44 stars rating. Fair. 1063 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 5%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$119~~Discounted rate:$113USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Comfort Inn JFK Airport
132-15 150th Avenue,
Jamaica, NY, 11430, US
19.72 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
3.7 stars rating. Good. 788 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 19%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$239~~Discounted rate:$194USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island
2695 Route 112,
Medford, NY, 11763, US
24.2 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
3.93 stars rating. Good. 1223 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 3%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$149~~Discounted rate:$145USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Comfort Inn Edgewater on Hudson River
725 River Rd.,
Edgewater, NJ, 07020, US
27.65 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.02 stars rating. Very Good. 1318 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$219~~Discounted rate:$198USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Comfort Inn Prospect Park-Brooklyn
150 20th Street,
Brooklyn, NY, 11232, US
29.22 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.04 stars rating. Very Good. 706 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$274~~Discounted rate:$247USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Quality Inn JFK Airport Rockaway Blvd
153-95 Rockaway Blvd,
Jamaica, NY, 11434, US
18.36 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
2.22 stars rating. Fair. 329 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$169~~Discounted rate:$152USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Avion Inn Near LGA Airport, an Ascend Collection Hotel
23-45 83rd Street,
East Elmhurst, NY, 11370, US
22.67 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
3.12 stars rating. Good. 389 reviews
$199USD/night
See Availability
Comfort Inn & Suites near Stadium
2477 Third Avenue,
Bronx, NY, 10451, US
25.12 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
3.97 stars rating. Good. 939 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 5%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$189~~Discounted rate:$180USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
NEW HOTEL
Sleep Inn
2239 Church Avenue,
Brooklyn, NY, 11226, US
27.5 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
3.86 stars rating. Good. 7 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$289~~Discounted rate:$260USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Cambria Hotel White Plains - Downtown
250 Main Street,
White Plains, NY, 10601, US
24.8 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.55 stars rating. Excellent. 2287 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 3%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$249~~Discounted rate:$242USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability
Westgate New York Grand Central
304 E. 42nd Street,
New York, NY, 10017, US
27.17 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
No Reviews Yet
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 3%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$247~~Discounted rate:$239USD/night
Special Rate
Fees included
See Availability
Rodeway Inn Near JFK Airport
136-05 Cranston Street,
Jamaica, NY, 11434, US
18.47 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
2.59 stars rating. Fair. 116 reviews
BOOK NOW AND SAVE 5%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$163~~Discounted rate:$155USD/night
Member Rate
See Availability

Change your dates to book properties below.

Sleep Inn Brooklyn - Sheepshead Bay
2646 E. 18th Street,
Brooklyn, NY, 11235, US
28.75 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
1.33 stars rating. Fair. 3 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
Rodeway Inn Bronx Zoo
3070-72 Webster Avenue,
Bronx, NY, 10467, US
23.44 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
3.82 stars rating. Good. 398 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
Sleep Inn JFK Airport Rockaway Blvd
153-75 Rockaway Blvd,
Jamaica, NY, 11434, US
18.37 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.11 stars rating. Very Good. 883 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
Rodeway Inn Brooklyn - Brownsville
1755 Pitkin Ave,
Brooklyn, NY, 11212, US
24.67 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
No Reviews Yet
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
Sleep Inn Bronx - Belmont
510 E. 185th Street, Building B,
Bronx, NY, 10458, US
23.8 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
3.76 stars rating. Good. 25 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
Cambria Hotel New York - Chelsea
123 W. 28th Street,
New York, NY, 10001, US
28.18 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.45 stars rating. Excellent. 3964 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
Sleep Inn Bronx - Soundview
1164 Wheeler Avenue,
Bronx, NY, 10472, US
22.78 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
No Reviews Yet
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
MainStay Suites Bronx - Belmont
510 E. 185th Street, Building A,
Bronx, NY, 10458, US
23.8 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
4.43 stars rating. Excellent. 7 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability
NEW HOTEL
Cambria Hotel New York Times Square
224 W 47th Street,
New York, NY, 10036, US
27.87 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
No Reviews Yet
Coming soonStart booking Jun 02, 2026
See Availability
Comfort Inn & Suites LaGuardia Airport
60-30 Maurice Avenue,
Maspeth, NY, 11378, US
23.75 mi from Old Bethpage, NY, US
3.9 stars rating. Good. 1567 reviews
Sold outfor your selected dates
See Availability

Old Bethpage hotels by brand

Good to know

Highest Price

$260

Lowest Price

$113

Avg. rating

0 hotels near Old Bethpage, NY, US match your filters

Below are additional hotels in the area that do not match your exact search criteria.

Comfort Inn Syosset-Long Island

Econo Lodge Hicksville - Long Island

Rodeway Inn Huntington Station - Melville

Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

Blue Angel Hotel NYC, an Ascend Collection Hotel

Mayfair Hotel, an Ascend Collection Hotel

Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport

Clarion Hotel & Conference Center Ronkonkoma MacArthur Airport

Comfort Inn JFK Airport

Comfort Inn Medford-Long Island

Comfort Inn Edgewater on Hudson River

Comfort Inn Prospect Park-Brooklyn

Quality Inn JFK Airport Rockaway Blvd

Avion Inn Near LGA Airport, an Ascend Collection Hotel

Comfort Inn & Suites near Stadium

Sleep Inn

Cambria Hotel White Plains - Downtown

Westgate New York Grand Central

Rodeway Inn Near JFK Airport

Change your dates to book properties below.

Sleep Inn Brooklyn - Sheepshead Bay

Rodeway Inn Bronx Zoo

Sleep Inn JFK Airport Rockaway Blvd

Rodeway Inn Brooklyn - Brownsville

Sleep Inn Bronx - Belmont

Cambria Hotel New York - Chelsea

Sleep Inn Bronx - Soundview

MainStay Suites Bronx - Belmont

Cambria Hotel New York Times Square

Comfort Inn & Suites LaGuardia Airport

Other Old Bethpage searches

Old Bethpage hotels by brand

Good to know

$260

$113

3.6 (21980 reviews)