5 hotels near Shelter Island, NY, US

5 hotels near Shelter Island, NY, US

Show points
    • Map

    • Sleep Inn & Suites Niantic North

      5 King Arthur,
      Niantic, CT, 06357-1212, US
      34.21 km from Shelter Island, NY, US
      4.1 stars rating. Very Good. 1097 reviews

      BOOK NOW AND SAVE 10%

      Strikethrough Rate:$121Discounted rate:$109USD/night
      Member Rate
      See Availability

    • Rodeway Inn & Suites Branford - Guilford

      81 Leetes Island Road,
      Branford, CT, 06405, US
      43.57 km from Shelter Island, NY, US
      4.05 stars rating. Very Good. 354 reviews

      BOOK NOW AND SAVE 5%

      Strikethrough Rate:$100Discounted rate:$95USD/night
      Member Rate
      See Availability

    • Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook - Westbrook

      1750 Boston Post Road,
      Old Saybrook, CT, 06475, US
      25.09 km from Shelter Island, NY, US
      3.38 stars rating. Good. 381 reviews

      BOOK NOW AND SAVE 5%

      Strikethrough Rate:$84Discounted rate:$80USD/night
      Member Rate
      See Availability

    • Rodeway Inn Waterford - New London

      211 Parkway North,
      Waterford, CT, 06385, US
      36.43 km from Shelter Island, NY, US
      4.2 stars rating. Excellent. 667 reviews

      BOOK NOW AND SAVE 15%

      Strikethrough Rate:$119Discounted rate:$102USD/night
      Member Rate
      See Availability

    • Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook

      100 Essex Rd.,
      Old Saybrook, CT, 06475, US
      27.93 km from Shelter Island, NY, US
      3.52 stars rating. Good. 1372 reviews

      BOOK NOW AND SAVE 10%

      Strikethrough Rate:$149Discounted rate:$134USD/night
      Member Rate
      See Availability

    Change your dates to book properties below.

    • Rodeway Inn Groton - New London

      425 Bridge St.,
      Groton, CT, 06340, US
      39.61 km from Shelter Island, NY, US
      2.9 stars rating. Fair. 438 reviews
      Sold outfor your selected dates
      See Availability

    Other Shelter Island searches

    Good to know

    Number of hotels

    6 hotels in Shelter Island

    Highest Price

    $134

    Lowest Price

    $80

    Avg. rating

    3.7 (4309 reviews)