4 hotels near Shelter Island, NY

4 hotels near Shelter Island, NY

Show points
    • List
    • 33
      Sleep Inn & Suites

      21.26 mi from destination

      4.11 stars rating. Very Good. 1055 reviews
      Save 10%
      Strikethrough Rate:$110Discounted rate:$99USD/night
      Member Rate
    • 43
      Quality Inn Old Saybrook - Westbrook

      17.35 mi from destination

      3.49 stars rating. Good. 1288 reviews
      Save 10%
      Strikethrough Rate:$115Discounted rate:$104USD/night
      Member Rate
    • 27
      Rodeway Inn Waterford - New London

      22.63 mi from destination

      4.2 stars rating. Excellent. 655 reviews
      Save 19%
      Strikethrough Rate:$114Discounted rate:$92USD/night
      Member Rate
    • 42
      Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Old Saybrook - Westbrook

      15.59 mi from destination

      3.41 stars rating. Good. 369 reviews
      Save 7%
      Strikethrough Rate:$89Discounted rate:$83USD/night
      Member Rate

    Other Shelter Island searches

    Good to know

    Number of hotels

    4 hotels in Shelter Island

    Highest Price

    $104

    Lowest Price

    $83

    Avg. rating

    3.8 (3367 reviews)