Hotels in Pine Island, NY – Choice Hotels

43
Sleep Inn & Suites Middletown - Goshen
8.58 mi from destination
4.26 stars rating. Excellent. 1275 reviews
Save 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$129~~Discounted rate:$116USD/night
Member Rate
38
AWARD WINNER
Sleep Inn & Suites Monroe - Woodbury
14.53 mi from destination
4.56 stars rating. Excellent. 1195 reviews
Save 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$125~~Discounted rate:$113USD/night
Member Rate
34
Quality Inn near Mountain Creek
9.83 mi from destination
3.62 stars rating. Good. 825 reviews
Save 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$166~~Discounted rate:$149USD/night
Member Rate
32
NEW HOTEL
Comfort Suites Central Valley - Woodbury
18.05 mi from destination
4.07 stars rating. Very Good. 30 reviews
Save 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$119~~Discounted rate:$107USD/night
Member Rate
11
Quality Inn Spring Valley - Nanuet
26.38 mi from destination
2.98 stars rating. Fair. 805 reviews
Save 7%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$145~~Discounted rate:$135USD/night
Member Rate
25
Econo Lodge Newton
24.8 mi from destination
3.4 stars rating. Good. 594 reviews
Save 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$89~~Discounted rate:$80USD/night
Member Rate
25
Rodeway Inn Milford - I-84
19.43 mi from destination
3.92 stars rating. Good. 423 reviews
Save 10%
Strikethrough Rate:~~$105~~Discounted rate:$95USD/night
Member Rate
2
NEW TO CHOICE
Rodeway Inn
27.28 mi from destination
No Reviews Yet
Coming soonStart booking Sep 04, 2026

Other Pine Island searches

Boutique Hotels in Pine Island

Hotel Deals in Pine Island

Extended Stay Hotels in Pine Island

Pet Friendly Hotels in Pine Island

Top Rated Hotels in Pine Island

Pine Island hotels by brand

Comfort Suites Hotels

Econo Lodge Hotels

Quality Inn Hotels

Rodeway Inn Hotels

Sleep Inn Hotels

Good to know

Number of hotels

8 hotels in Pine Island

Highest Price

$149

Lowest Price

$80

Avg. rating

3.8 (5147 reviews)